I’ve recently become fixated on the phenomenon known as Weight Watchers 2 Ingredient Dough. In case you’re feed hasn’t been inundated with pictures of bagels, cinnamon rolls, and pizzas recently and don’t know what it is, 2 Ingredient Dough is a 1:1 mix of self-rising flour and Fage plain 0% yogurt (consistency is important, and Fage is the thickest commercial greek yogurt.) A recipe of 1 cup flour to 1 cup yogurt will yield (for me, anyway) 4 bagels, two pizzas, or several apple turnovers (which I prefer to the afore-mentioned cinnamon buns). For those of us on Weight Watchers, these goodies are a low-point bonanza, letting us eat bagels & pizza while only eating a couple of points. But I digress. I can share other recipes, but this post is about one thing: how to cook the BEST 2 ingredient bagel.
I’ve seen two cooking methods floating around; one calls for simply baking the bagels, and the other starts with the traditional step of boiling the bagels first and then baking. Now I’m a New Yorker. Bagels are important. If you buy your bagels in a bag from the freezer section in your local supermarket, you might not care about the difference of boiled vs. baked. But for those of us who debate which bagel place is best, grew up going to the bagel place every Sunday morning to pick up a baker’s dozen, and travel down to their home town to pick up ‘real’ bagels because they’re just not as good where you live (ok, yes, that would be me), it’s a question who’s time has come.
I started out with a half-recipe of dough, which I was leftover from my pizza the night before, rolled into a ball and thrown in the fridge. First, a word about the dough. Although the proportion is 1:1, in my experience, you will need to add a little more flour to get it to the right consistency; otherwise it’s a little too sticky. It shouldn’t stick to your hands when rolled into a ball or on the rolling pin when rolling out to make a pizza. So sprinkle with flour as needed. And, while I left the dough unseasoned this time, the last time I made the bagels, I added Penzey’s Mural of Flavor to the mix , but there’s an infinite variety of flavors you can add to your dough. For pizza, Italian seasoning and garlic are great, and if using for apple turnovers, I like to add cinnamon or Penzey’s Pie Spice.
I cut my dough in half and made two nice-sized bagels. about 4″ in diameter. I prefer them a little on the flatter side, so I ‘schmush’ gently with my palm after they’re shaped. This makes them more like the flagels (aka flattened bagels), which I’ve made road trips to New City for. Hint; it gives you more of the yummy ‘outside’ of the bagel than a rounder bagel, which has more of the doughy inside. I’m sure you can tell which I prefer.
I brushed my first bagel, the baker, with an egg wash, sprinkled on some sunflower seeds (I’m experimenting with toppings, too), and put in my air fryer for about 12 minutes at 350 degrees. You can use an oven, of course, but the air fryer is my new toy, and it really gets both sides of the bagel nice and browned. While that was cooking, I boiled up a pot of water and once it came to a rolling boil, put bagel #2 in and boiled for 2 minutes, turning over after the 1st minute. After that I drained, brushed with the egg wash, sunflowered, and also put in the air fryer. I checked the bagels after 10 minutes and gave them a couple of more minutes to get nicely browned. Total cooking time is between 11-15 minutes. I think this will vary depending upon personal tastes and oven temperature variations. Just check them and pull ’em out when they look good to you.
The Results!
Visally, they both look great, but the boiled bagel is definitely larger, and has a ‘puffier’ feel. But what do they look like inside? Sure enough, the boiled bagel is less dense, and has more, and larger air pockets. The interior of the baked only also felt stickier to the touch.
On to the the taste test. I toasted both of my bagels; I’ve found that the 2 Ingredient Bagels, while a great way to be able to have my bagels and eat them too, need a light toast; it’s a dense dough, and the gummier inside greatly benefits from it. I toast just enough to dry out the inside just a bit. I like them with eggs (because eggs are free on the new Weight Watchers, and who doesn’t like egg sandwiches?)
And the winner is…Boiled! Those air pockets made the bagel cook a little better, yielding a less sticky interior, and the outer crust was, well…crustier, and packed a more satisfying crunch and chew combination.
All in all, it’s a subtle difference, but I’ll be taking the extra few minutes to boil my bagels. For those of you who aren’t as fanatical, boiled might not be worth the extra time, and just baked might be fine or you. Either way, make a bagel, grab a schmear, and enjoy!
Note about toppings: I really preferred my everything bagel mix to the sunflower seeds. I’ve heard that Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel spice is great, but I didn’t have that, so I mixed my own from what I had on hand: black & white sesame seeds, dried minced garlic, onion flakes, and kosher salt. Yum.